Is Executive Coaching Worth It? What Business Owners in Ireland Say

The short answer is yes, but only when it is the right fit and you go in ready to do the work.

The longer answer is worth reading, because executive coaching in Ireland is a significant investment of time, money, and energy, and you deserve an honest picture of what it actually delivers, when it works, when it does not, and how to know if it is right for you.

I have been coaching business owners and executives across Ireland for over twenty years. I have worked with people who came to me sceptical and left transformed. I have also seen coaching not work, and I want to be honest about why. Because the goal here is not to sell you something. It is to help you make a genuinely informed decision.

What does executive coaching in Ireland actually involve?

First, let us clear up what executive coaching is and is not. It is not therapy. It is not someone telling you what decisions to make.

Executive coaching is a focused professional relationship designed to help you perform better, think more clearly, lead more effectively, and grow in ways that matter to your business and your life. A good coach will challenge your assumptions, help you see blind spots you cannot see from inside your own situation, hold you accountable to your goals, and give you tools and frameworks that create lasting change rather than short-term motivation.

In the Irish market, executive coaching typically covers areas like leadership development, decision-making under pressure, managing difficult relationships at work, building confident communication, navigating growth or transition, and personal performance. The best coaching draws on all of these as needed, because in practice they are rarely separate.

Sessions are usually one-to-one, held regularly over a set period, and structured around your specific challenges and goals. The work happens in the sessions and, just as importantly, between them.

When executive coaching works, what actually changes?

This is the question that matters most to any business owner considering coaching, and it deserves a straight answer. Here is what I see change consistently in the people I work with.

Clearer, faster decision-making

One of the most immediate shifts I see in executives and business owners is that they stop going around in circles on decisions that have been sitting on their desk for weeks. Not because coaching gives them the answers, but because it helps them identify what is actually blocking the decision. Sometimes it is missing information. More often it is fear, or a conflicting value, or an old story about failure. When you can see that clearly, the decision becomes much simpler.

A client came to me once who had been delaying a significant hire for six months. Within three sessions we had identified that the real issue was not uncertainty about the candidate. It was a fear of what the hire would mean about how much the business had grown and the responsibility that came with it. Once he saw that, he made the hire within a week. The business grew significantly as a result.

Stronger leadership and team performance

I have worked with leaders in Ireland whose teams were capable on paper but consistently underperforming. In almost every case, the issue was not the team. It was the leadership dynamic, something in how the leader was communicating, delegating, or managing conflict that was creating drag.

Good executive coaching helps leaders understand their own style, see how it lands with others, and develop the range to flex that style when the situation demands it. The downstream effect on team performance is often significant and faster than most leaders expect.

Better performance under pressure

Pressure is where most leadership development breaks down. You can have all the right frameworks and all the right intentions, but when things get stressful, most people revert to their defaults. One of the real strengths of good coaching is that it works on those defaults directly, helping you build new responses to pressure that become habitual over time.

The business owners and executives I coach who invest consistently in this work make better calls under pressure, recover faster from setbacks, and are far less likely to burn out. That has real commercial value, not just personal value.

Confidence and credibility in high-stakes situations

Whether it is a major pitch, a board presentation, a difficult conversation with a co-founder, or leading a team through a period of uncertainty, high-stakes moments are where confidence is tested most. Executive coaching builds the specific kind of grounded confidence that holds up in those moments, not because it removes the nerves, but because it builds a deeper trust in your own judgement and capability.

When does executive coaching not work?

I said at the start that I wanted to be honest, and this is the honest part.

Coaching does not work when the person going into it is not genuinely ready to look at themselves. If you are hoping that coaching will fix the people around you while leaving you unchanged, it will be a frustrating experience. The work, by definition, starts with you.

It also does not work well when there is no clear intention for what you want to change or achieve. Vague investment produces vague results. The people who get the most from coaching are the ones who come in with some sense of what they are trying to solve, even if it shifts as the work progresses.

And it does not work when the relationship between coach and client is wrong. Compatibility matters enormously. A technically skilled coach who is not the right fit for you personally will produce far less than a coach who challenges and connects with you in the right way. This is why most good coaches offer an initial conversation before any commitment is made, and it is worth using that conversation properly.

How do you know if you are ready for executive coaching?

Here are the honest indicators I look for when someone comes to me considering coaching.

You are ready if you are genuinely open to the possibility that some of what is holding your business or your leadership back might be coming from you. Not all of it. Circumstances are real. Difficult people are real. But some of it.

You are ready if you are willing to commit the time. Coaching is not a quick fix. Real change takes consistent engagement over months, not weeks.

You are ready if there is a genuine challenge you are trying to navigate, whether that is scaling a business, managing a difficult leadership transition, rebuilding confidence after a setback, or getting out from under the overwhelm that comes with running a company in Ireland right now.

And you are ready if you are at a stage where the cost of staying the same is higher than the cost of changing. Most of the people who come to me are already there. They are just looking for the right support to make the move.

What makes a great executive coach in Ireland?

There are a lot of coaches in Ireland. The market has grown significantly over the last decade and the quality varies widely. Here is what to look for.

Experience that is directly relevant to where you are. A coach who has worked extensively with business owners and executives in Ireland will understand the specific pressures of that context, the size of the market, the relational nature of Irish business culture, the particular challenges of scaling a company here.

A track record you can verify. Ask for examples of outcomes. A good coach will be able to speak specifically about the kinds of results their clients achieve, without betraying confidentiality. If they can only speak in abstractions, keep looking.

Someone who challenges you, not just supports you. Coaching that only validates what you already think is not coaching. You need someone who will tell you what they actually see, even when it is uncomfortable. Warmth and directness are not opposites. The best coaches do both.

And compatibility. This is harder to define but you will know it. You need to be able to be honest with this person. You need to trust that they are on your side. And you need to feel, after an initial conversation, that something shifted. That is usually a reliable signal.

A word from over twenty years of doing this work

I came to coaching because I needed it myself. I was running my business in my twenties, burning the candle at both ends, and it put me in a hospital bed being treated for a suspected heart attack. That experience changed everything. It taught me that clarity is not a luxury. It is essential for both survival and sustainable success.

Since then I have coached thousands of people across Ireland and beyond, from individual professionals to business owners running large teams, to executives in global organisations. I have appeared as a resident life coach on Virgin Media, worked with the BBC, and been a regular voice on Newstalk. I have written two books, including the bestselling Break Through.

But what I am most proud of is not any of that. It is the people who came to me stuck and left moving. The ones who came to me doubting themselves and left trusting themselves. The ones who came to me carrying weight they had been carrying for years and left lighter.

That is what good executive coaching in Ireland can do. Not magic. Not overnight transformation. But real, lasting change in how you think, how you lead, and what you are capable of.

So is executive coaching worth it?

For the right person, at the right time, with the right coach, the answer is consistently yes. Not because it is comfortable or easy, but because the alternative, staying exactly where you are while the cost of that becomes clearer every year, tends to be more expensive in the long run.

If you have read this far, you are probably already somewhere close to ready. The question is just what the right next step looks like for you.

Interested in working together?

If you are a business owner or executive in Ireland considering coaching, I would love to have a conversation. Not a sales call. Just an honest conversation about where you are, what you are trying to solve, and whether working together makes sense. There is no pressure and no obligation.

→  Get in touch with Mark, Contact & Coaching Enquiries

And if people, pressure, or difficult dynamics at work are a significant part of what is costing you right now, my masterclass on dealing with narcissists and bullies is a practical place to start. It is available immediately and covers exactly the kind of interpersonal challenges that drain the energy and focus of even the most capable leaders.

→  How to Deal with Narcissists & Bullies, Mark's Masterclass

For regular, honest content on leadership, resilience, and personal performance delivered to your inbox every two weeks, sign up for my free newsletter at markfennell.ie.